Document Type

Article

Publication Date

1992

Publication Information

25 Ind. L. Rev. 1419 (1991-1992)

Abstract

Summarizing the developments in Indiana tort law is a daunting, perhaps impossible task. In more than 115 reported opinions, state and federal courts wrestled with issues, many of them issues of first impression, which ranged across the spectrum of tort law. A constant thread runs through many of these cases. The thread is duty. Time and again during the past year, Indiana courts were required to decide whether a particular set of facts gave rise to a duty of care by the defendant or an obligation of avoidance by the plaintiff.

Some of the cases involved novel legal duties, while others gave modern answers to time-worn problems. Whatever the ultimate result, one aspect of the decisions stands out: the courts did not resolve the issue of duty along any consistent view of the notion of obligation and responsibility. Although the Indiana Supreme Court purported to announce a comprehensive new test for the determination of duty during 1991, Indiana does not in fact have a single, coherent theory of duty. Rather, it has four competing models: a model of duty based on relationship, a model based on foreseeability of harm, a model based on public policy, and a model based on community values.

Part I of this Article begins the exploration of this theme by describing Indiana's new test for duty. Part II examines three sets of cases decided by the Indiana Supreme Court and demonstrates that the four models of duty remain entrenched despite this new test. Part III applies these models to duty decisions in the areas of physical, psychic, and economic torts, as well as to the plaintiff's own obligation of due care, and proves that the reliance on the disparate models has frustrated any coherent pattern of doctrinal development in the area of duty. Part IV provides some tentative conclusions about the general direction of duty analysis in Indiana.

Comments

Reprinted with permission of Indiana Law Review.

Share

COinS
 
 

To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.