Document Type

Brief

Case Name

United States of America v. Mujera Benjamin Lung'aho

Publication Date

10-12-2026

Abstract

No. 23-3696
United States of America v. Mujera Benjamin Lung'aho

On Remand from the Supreme Court of the United States, Case No. 25-6124

Appeal from the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Arkansas
Case No. 20-cr-288-DPM-1 Hon. D.P. Marshall Jr.

From the Summary of Argument

In light of Landor v. Louisiana Department of Corrections & Public Safety, Section 844(f)(1) of Title 18, as applied to Mr. Lung’aho, exceeds Congress’s constitutional authority. It is a fundamental principle of constitutional law that the federal government lacks a general police power. Therefore, there are real and enforceable limits on Congress’s ability to use its spending power to create, prosecute, and punish federal crimes. Section 844(f)(1), as applied to Mr. Lung’aho, exceeds those limits. The spending power is simply not a valid vehicle for the creation of this federal crime. Nor does it become one through the Necessary and Proper Clause. Applying § 844(f)(1) to garden-variety local arson threatens the values that federalism was designed to promote and protect. Not only does § 844(f)(1) exceed the bounds of Congress’s enumerated powers, but the unchecked expansion of federal criminal jurisdiction over these matters is inconsistent with the text and structure of our Constitution.

Comments

Richard W. Garnett submits this brief in support of Defendant-Appellant Mujera Lung’aho. Garnett is a professor at Notre Dame Law School. He teaches and writes in the areas of constitutional law, criminal law, the First Amendment, and law and religion. He has previously written about the constitutionality of criminal statutes enacted under the Spending Clause and the Necessary and Proper Clause. He has a strong interest in the sound development of this area of the law.

Table of Authorities includes:

Richard W. Garnett, The New Federalism, the Spending Power, and Federal Criminal Law, 89 Cornell L. Rev. 1 (2003)

Share

COinS