Natural Law at the Foundation of Global Constitutionalism
Document Type
Book Chapter
Publication Date
2023
Abstract
From the Publisher
Chapter 15
A common view holds that law within nation-states consists of positive law and constitutional law. Positive law is law made through affirmative action incorporating consent of some sort by the governed. Constitutional law is positive law that is more difficult to change than the standard forms. At the international level, the common view is that there is no constitution. All law is positive law. Contributors to this Handbook, however, find constitutionalist features at the international level. This chapter takes that analysis further arguing that yet a third category of law underlies both constitutional law and positive law. Natural law theory and principles play a critical role in accounting for the binding nature of law and for its enduring higher norms, both the jus cogens and inherent general principles. Without them law is not law. Some authors include certain general principles and jus cogens in the category of constitutionalist principles, such as the principle of equality and the prohibition on the use of force. Constitutions, like all of positive law, can be amended or terminated tomorrow. Natural law norms endure. Despite its essential role, natural law has been suppressed for reasons discussed in the chapter.
Recommended Citation
O'Connell, Mary Ellen, "Natural Law at the Foundation of Global Constitutionalism" (2023). Book Chapters. 41.
https://scholarship.law.nd.edu/book_chapters/41
Publication Information
in Handbook on Global Constitutionalism 209 (Anthony F. Lang & Antje Wiener eds., 2d ed. 2023).