Document Type

Article

Publication Date

2004

Publication Information

64 La. L. Rev. (2004)

Abstract

Are cohabitation and marriage similar enough to warrant similar legal treatment? Earlier public reports on cohabitation have focused on the question of whether cohabitation before marriage increases or decreases the divorce rate.

But increasingly cohabitation is being proposed not as a testing ground for marriage, but as a functional substitute for it. The trend in family law and scholarship in Europe and Canada is to treat married and cohabiting couples similarly, or even identically.

In this country, the American Law Institute [ALl] recently proposed that, at least when it comes to the law of dissolution, couples who have been living together for a substantial period of time should be treated the same as married couples. The ALI recommendations carry particularly intellectual weight, given they are the product often years of study by one of the most influential and mainstream voices on legal reform.

This essay evaluates (a) the weight of social science evidence on the extent to which, and the condition under which, cohabitation is the functional equivalent of marriage (b) the mechanisms, from a law and economics perspective, through which formal recognition of a relationship as a marriage may boost well-being, and (c) the likely consequences of blurring the legal distinction between formal and informal unions, as the ALI proposes.

Generally, we see too many problems with cohabitation defined as an alternative to marriage to believe that law and social policy should actively support this emerging family form. Looking at the weight of social science evidence on marriage and cohabitation, this paper suggests what we believe is a middle ground: law and public policy should distinguish between cohabitation as a prelude to marriage (or a courtship strategy) and cohabitation as an alternative to marriage. The evidence, we suggest, points to many fewer problems with the former than the latter.

Included in

Family Law Commons

Share

COinS
 
 

To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.